File under: Great Literary Putdowns in History (I don’t have the essay Vidal wrote about Norman Mailer, though I do recall him comparing one of Mailer’s books to “three days of menstrual flow”)
Gore Vidal on Henry Miller:
“At least half of Sexus consists of tributes to the wonder of Henry Miller. At a glance men realize that he knows. Women realize that he is. Mara-Mona: ‘I’m falling in love with the strangest man on earth. You frighten me, you’re so gentle… I feel almost as if I were with a god.’ Even a complete stranger is his for the asking the moment she sees him. But, uniquely, they both prefer to chat. The subject? Let the countess speak for herself: ‘Whoever the woman is you love, I pity her… Nobody can hold you for long… You make friends easily, I’m sure. And yet there is no one whom you can really call your friend. You are alone. You will always be alone.’ She asks him to embrace her. He does, chastely. Her life is now changed. ‘You have helped, in a way… You always help, indirectly. You can’t help radiating energy, and that is something. People lean on you, but you don’t know why.’”
“After two more pages of this keen analysis, she tells him, ‘Your sexual virility is only the sign of a greater power, which you haven’t begun to use.’ She never quite tells him what this power is, but it must be something pretty super because everyone else can also sense it humming away. As a painter friend (male) says, ‘I don’t know any writer in America who has greater gifts than you. I’ve always believed in you — and I will even if you prove to be a failure.’ This is heady praise indeed, considering that the painter has yet to read anything Miller has written.” (…)
“As a lover, Henry Miller is a national resource, on the order of Yosemite National Park. Later, exhausted by his unearthly potency, she realizes that for the first time she has met Man… one for whom post coitum is not triste but rhetorical. When lesser men sleep, Miller talks about the cosmos, the artist, the sterility of modern life. Or in his own words: ‘… our conversations were like passages out of The Magic Mountain, only more virulent, more exalted, more sustained, more provocative, more inflammable, more dangerous, more menacing, and much more, ever so much more, exhausting.’ “
“Yet Henry never seems to do anything for anyone, other than to provide moments of sexual glory which we must take on faith. He does, however, talk a lot and the people he knows are addicted to his conversation. ‘Don’t stop talking now, please…,’ begs a woman whose life is being changed, as Henry in a manic mood tells her all sorts of liberating things like ‘Nothing would ever be bad or ugly or evil — if we really let ourselves go. But it’s hard to make people understand that.’ To which the only answer is that of another straight man in the text who says, ‘You said it, Henry. Jesus, having you around is like getting a shot in the arm.’ For a man who boasts of writing nothing but the truth, I find it more than odd that not once in the course of a long narrative does anyone say, ‘Henry, you’re full of shit.’ It is possible, of course, that no one ever did, but I doubt it.”
-from Vidal’s Sexually Speaking
Oh, excellent. Thanks!